The beloved Old Town Coffee and Chocolates in Eureka has suddenly closed both of its locations, leaving the community in shock. Once celebrated as the ‘Business of the Year,’ the café has faced serious financial troubles over the past year. The closure began on May 1, with a sign claiming a power outage, but other businesses nearby remained unaffected. Since then, both locations have not reopened, and attempts to contact the owner have gone unanswered.
• The owner, Amanda Slinkard, has not made loan payments since June 2025 and owes over $77,000.
• A lien notice indicates she also owes around $73,000 in taxes to the state.
• Social media posts from the café hinted at financial struggles and rising costs.
• Some furniture and decor have been removed, suggesting a permanent closure.
This situation highlights the challenges small businesses face, especially in tough economic times. The café was a cherished part of the community, and its sudden closure raises concerns about the future of local businesses. Residents are left wondering if a new owner will step in to revive the beloved spot.
Enjoying the read? Subscribe for free to one of the fastest-growing newsletters and get weekly coffee news (TL;DR updates) delivered right to your inbox.